Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) are a popular form of equity compensation, especially for employees working in tech hubs like California. They provide a powerful incentive for employees to contribute to the company’s growth, while also allowing companies to attract top talent. However, the tax implications of RSUs can become complicated when employees move across state lines during their vesting period. In particular, California’s pro-rata rule for RSU taxation is a key consideration for individuals who relocate to another state.
In this blog post, we’ll explore the pro-rata rule, its implications for RSUs granted in California, and the steps employees can take to navigate this complex area of taxation. Whether you’re planning a move or have already relocated, understanding this rule is essential for effective tax planning.
What Are RSUs?
Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) are a form of equity compensation granted by an employer to an employee. Unlike stock options, RSUs don’t require the employee to purchase shares at a predetermined price. Instead, RSUs represent a promise to deliver company stock (or its cash equivalent) to the employee at a future date, typically tied to a vesting schedule.
Vesting schedules are often time-based, performance-based, or a combination of both. For instance, an employee might receive a grant of 1,000 RSUs, with 25% vesting each year over four years. Upon vesting, the shares are considered income and subject to federal and state income taxes, as well as payroll taxes.
California’s Tax Stance
California is known for its high-income tax rates and aggressive tax enforcement. When it comes to equity compensation like RSUs, the state takes a comprehensive approach to taxation. Even if an employee moves out of California before their RSUs fully vest, California may claim the right to tax a portion of the income derived from those RSUs based on the period of service performed in the state.
The Pro-Rata Rule Explained
The pro-rata rule is a method used to allocate income from RSUs between different states based on the time the employee spent working in each state during the vesting period. For RSUs granted in California, this means that the state will tax a proportionate share of the RSU income, even if the employee has relocated to a lower-tax or no-tax state before the RSUs vest.
How the Pro-Rata Rule Works
The pro-rata rule divides the total number of days in the RSU vesting period into two categories:
Days Worked in California:Â The number of days the employee performed services in California during the vesting period.
Total Vesting Period Days:Â The total number of days in the RSU vesting period.
The ratio of California workdays to total vesting days determines the portion of the RSU income that is subject to California income tax. The formula looks like this:
California Taxable Income = Total RSU Income x (California Workdays / Total Vesting Period Days)
Example:
Let’s assume the following scenario:
An employee is granted 1,000 RSUs on January 1, 2022, with a four-year vesting schedule (25% vesting annually).
The employee works in California from January 1, 2022, to December 31, 2023, and then relocates to Texas, a no-income-tax state, on January 1, 2024.
For the RSUs that vest on January 1, 2024, the calculation would be as follows:
California Workdays:Â 730 days (January 1, 2022, to December 31, 2023)
Total Vesting Period Days:Â 1,096 days (January 1, 2022, to January 1, 2024)
The pro-rata share subject to California tax is:
California Taxable Income = Total RSU Income x (730 / 1,096)
If the RSUs are valued at $40 per share upon vesting, the total income from the 250 RSUs vesting on January 1, 2024, would be $10,000. Using the pro-rata rule, California could tax approximately 66.6% of that income, or $6,660.
Challenges and Considerations
Tracking Workdays
One of the most significant challenges for employees is accurately tracking the number of workdays spent in each state during the vesting period. This requires meticulous record-keeping and documentation, such as calendars, travel itineraries, and employer verification.
Double Taxation Risk
Employees who relocate to another state may face the risk of double taxation. For example, the new state of residence may also tax the RSU income. In such cases, employees can often claim a credit for taxes paid to California, but this depends on the tax laws of the new state.
Impact on Tax Planning
The pro-rata rule complicates tax planning for employees with RSUs. For instance, moving to a state with no income tax, like Texas or Florida, may not provide the expected tax savings if a substantial portion of the RSU income remains taxable in California.
Steps to Navigate the Pro-Rata Rule
1. Understand Your Grant Details
Review the terms of your RSU grant, including the vesting schedule, grant date, and any performance conditions. This will help you determine the total vesting period and calculate the allocation of taxable income.
2. Track Your Workdays
Maintain detailed records of your workdays in each state. This information is critical for accurately applying the pro-rata rule and avoiding disputes with tax authorities.
3. Consult With Us
Given the complexity of the pro-rata rule, working with us is essential. We can help you:
Calculate the pro-rata allocation.
File the appropriate state tax returns.
Claim credits for taxes paid to California, if applicable.
4. Consider Timing Your Move
If you’re considering relocating, the timing of your move can significantly impact your tax liability. For example, moving after the majority of your RSUs have vested may reduce the portion of income subject to California tax.
5. Negotiate Tax Assistance
Some employers offer tax assistance or gross-ups to employees who face significant tax liabilities on equity compensation. If you’re planning a move, discuss this option with your employer.
Planning for the Future
The pro-rata rule highlights the importance of proactive tax planning for employees who receive RSU compensation. By understanding how this rule applies, tracking your workdays, and seeking professional advice, you can minimize your tax liability and avoid unpleasant surprises.
If you’re contemplating a move or need assistance with RSU taxation, reach out to us. We specialize in equity compensation and multi-state taxation and can help you develop a tailored strategy to navigate the complexities of the pro-rata rule and achieve your financial goals.
Final Thoughts
California’s pro-rata rule for RSUs underscores the state’s commitment to taxing income earned within its borders, even when employees move out of state. For those planning to relocate, understanding this rule and its implications is critical. With careful planning and the right guidance, you can manage your RSU taxation effectively and make the most of your equity compensation.
Need help tracking your tax allocation? At AG Wealth Management, we're specialized in providing tax and financial planning advice for equity compensated tech professionals. Contact us today to request a spreadsheet that simplifies the process and ensures accurate reporting.